Over the years, I have asked hundreds of participants in management seminars to describe the characteristics of the best managers with whom they have ever worked. It's encouraging that nearly everyone recalled someone who fit that description, which led me to the conclusion that most employees know what it takes to be a great manager.
One of the most frequently cited attributes of a great manager is consistency. I have repeatedly heard statements like, "They walk the talk" and "Their actions are consistent with their words." However, sometimes it is difficult for us as managers to evaluate ourselves to see if we do meet the criteria of great managers.
Ken Wilber, a contemporary American philosopher, has developed an integral map that I have found to be a valuable tool in assessing how well we maintain our integrity and consistency in managing our organizations. Wilber defines the need for an integral map: "What is the point of using this integral map? First, the integral map helps make sure that you are 'touching all the bases.'
If you are trying to fly over the
The map is divided into quadrants. Each quadrant represents a different way to look at yourself as a manager in the context of your organization. As Wilber explains, "[The map] shows the 'I' (the inside of the individual), the 'it' (the outside of the individual), the 'we' (the inside of the collective) and the 'its' (the outside of the collective). In other words, the four quadrants which are the four basic ways of looking at anything turn out to be fairly simple: they are the inside and the outside of the individual and the collective."
Starting in the upper left quadrant (UL), the internal-individual view, you can observe your thoughts, feelings and beliefs. For example, you might believe that it is important that people who work together be respectful of one another. If you see someone being treated disrespectfully, you will probably feel anger. You may think that the person being disrespectful is immature or rude. All of these reactions are your internal individual thoughts, feelings and beliefs until you take action in the exterior where it can be viewed by others.
The upper-right quadrant (
This brings us to the lower-left quadrant (LL), the interior-collective. Wilber describes the interior-collective quadrant: "Notice that every 'I' is in relationship with other 'I's, which means that every 'I' is a member of numerous 'we's. These 'we's' represent not just individual but group (or collective) consciousness, or culture in the broadest sense." The culture of an organization is evident in the invisible rules, shared values and shared feelings that the group holds.
If you have ever spent time at an IBM office and then at an Apple Computer office, you would sense that they are two distinctly different corporate cultures. Mergers often fail because the challenge to integrate two different cultures may be so difficult to meet.
One of the best ways to learn about the culture of a team is for a manager to listen to employees' conversations at informal company settings, like the water cooler or lunch room. In this setting, you might hear employees criticize the manager whose actions toward a disrespectful employee were not consistent with previously stated values.
The outside of the culture is the lower-right quadrant (LR) or the exterior-collective
perspective. These are the objective systems in an organization, like the written policies and procedures. For example, our manager might have a conversation (
If we want to be consistent as managers, then we need to look at all four quadrants. Obstacles to high-performing teams are the cynicism, resentment and resignation that occur as a result of managers who act inconsistently. The manager who declares (
In a Harvard Business Review article titled, "Level 5 Leadership," Jim Collins, author of Good to Great and Built to Last, describes a competent manager as one who "organizes people and resources toward the effective and efficient pursuit of predetermined objectives." He contrasts this with the next higher level, an effective leader, who "catalyzes commitment to and stimulates the group to high-performance standards." An integral manager is one who maintains integrity in all four of the quadrants this is the key to stimulating high performance and becoming a great manager.
Mark Taylor, MBA, DLP, is the President of TAYLOR Systems Engineering Corporation and the Chief Logistics Officer of RedRoller, Inc., the world's first free Internet-based shopping service for shipping that compares the rates and delivery options of multiple carriers. He has been featured as an industry expert on ABC News and in the New York Times and is the author of Computerized Shipping Systems: Increasing Profit & Productivity Through Technology. He can be reached at Mark@RedRoller.com.